Windows in a Rented Flat: Who Pays for Repair and Replacement, Landlord or Tenant?
7 minutes read
Who pays for new windows in a rented flat depends on whether it is a repair or a modernisation. If windows are defective, leaking or worn out, the landlord must repair or replace them at their own cost; that follows from § 535 BGB. If they replace working windows with windows with better energy performance, they may pass part of the cost on to the rent through a modernisation rent increase: 8 per cent a year, less the maintenance costs that were due anyway, and limited by a cap.
This article explains the distinction, the calculation and the rights of tenants and landlords. It describes German tenancy law (as at September 2026) and does not replace legal advice. If your rented home is elsewhere, tenancy law there will differ; check the rules that apply in your country.
Windows in a Rented Flat: The Basic Rule
Under § 535 (1) sentence 2 BGB, the landlord must let the property to the tenant in a condition suitable for contractual use and keep it in that condition during the tenancy. Windows that close tightly, can be opened and protect against the weather are naturally part of that.
It follows that:
- Repairs to frames, hardware, seals and glass are in principle borne by the landlord.
- Replacement of worn-out windows is repair work, likewise a matter for the landlord.
- Defects must be reported by the tenant to the landlord without delay.
A valid minor-repairs clause in the tenancy agreement can make tenants contribute to minor repairs to parts that are exposed to their frequent access, such as window handles. The validity of such clauses depends on monetary limits and wording.
Repair, Modernisation or Both?
| Measure | Classification | Cost consequence for the tenant |
|---|---|---|
| Replacing a defective seal, adjusting hardware | Maintenance | no rent increase |
| Replacing rotten timber windows with equivalent ones | Repair | no rent increase |
| Replacing working old windows with energy-saving windows | Modernisation (§ 555b BGB) | levy possible |
| Replacing worn-out windows with markedly better ones | modernising repair | levy only for the modernisation share |
§ 555b BGB counts among modernisation measures, among other things, structural alterations that sustainably save final energy in relation to the rented property. New, better-insulating windows typically fall under this.
The most common situation in practice is modernising repair: the old windows are at the end of their life anyway, but the landlord fits better ones. They may then pass on only the part that goes beyond mere repair.
How the Modernisation Levy Is Calculated
Under § 559 BGB the landlord can raise the annual rent by 8 per cent of the modernisation costs spent on the flat. Costs that would have been needed for maintenance measures are not included; they may be estimated.
Simplified example:
- Cost of the window replacement for one flat: 10,000 euros
- Share that would have been incurred anyway for mere repair (estimated): 3,000 euros
- Modernisation costs that can be passed on: 7,000 euros
- Annual rent increase: 8 per cent of 7,000 euros = 560 euros, so about 46.67 euros a month
If funding is used, § 559a BGB applies: costs covered by grants from public budgets are not among the costs that can be passed on. With low-interest public loans, the amount of the increase is reduced by the annual amount of the interest reduction. If the landlord in the example receives a 15 per cent grant on the eligible costs, the levy falls accordingly.
Cap
§ 559 (3a) BGB limits the increase: within six years the monthly rent may rise because of modernisation by no more than 3 euros per square metre of living space. If the rent before the increase is below 7 euros per square metre, the limit is 2 euros per square metre.
Notice and Tenants' Rights
Under § 555c BGB the landlord must announce a modernisation in text form at the latest three months before it begins, with the nature and extent of the measure, expected start and duration and the expected rent increase. Exempt are measures that affect the rented property only insignificantly and lead only to an insignificant rent increase.
Tenants must in principle tolerate a properly announced modernisation. They can, however, invoke undue hardship, and after receipt of the notice there is a special right to terminate. The deadlines for objections are short; if in doubt, get advice from a tenants' association.
What the 2026 Tenancy Law Reform Could Change
On 29 April 2026 the Federal Government adopted a draft bill to reform tenancy law. Among other things it provides for raising the value limit for the simplified procedure for rent increases after modernisation from 10,000 to 20,000 euros. According to reports from July 2026, the draft was still in the parliamentary process and not in force (as at September 2026). Until it is passed, the current law governs.
When Tenants Can Reduce the Rent
Leaking or defective windows can constitute a defect in the rented property that impairs its suitability for contractual use, for example with severe draughts, rain coming in or a window that can no longer be closed. A rent reduction then comes into consideration for as long as the defect exists. A condition is that the tenant has reported the defect. How large a reduction may be depends on the individual case; there are no flat percentages. Anyone reducing the rent should take advice beforehand, because too large a reduction can lead to arrears.
During a window replacement itself there may also be disturbance, for example through noise and dirt. With energy modernisations, under § 536 (1a) BGB a disturbance is disregarded for three months to the extent that it is due to the energy measure.
Special Case: Owner-Occupied Flat Let to a Tenant
If the let flat is an owner-occupied flat in an owners' association, the windows belong to the common property. The landlord-owner cannot decide the replacement alone but needs a resolution of the owners' association; details in the article Replacing windows in an owners' association. Towards the tenant they remain obliged to remedy defects all the same.
Practical Tips for Tenants
- Report defects in writing: with date, photos and description, such as draught, damp or defective hardware.
- Set a deadline: for remedy, reasonable and in writing.
- Do not replace them yourself: unauthorised interference with the rented property can trigger claims for compensation by the landlord.
- Check notices: do the statements on costs, maintenance deduction and cap add up?
- Ventilate properly: new, airtight windows change the room climate; advice in the article Avoiding mould after replacing windows.
Practical Tips for Landlords
- Document the condition: the age and damage of the old windows evidence the maintenance share.
- Quotes with separate items: this makes the split into repair and modernisation easier. How to compare quotes is shown in the article Comparing window quotes.
- Check funding: BEG funding is also possible for let residential buildings; the application must be made before the contract is signed.
- Announce in good time and in full: formal errors can jeopardise the rent increase.
Checklist
- Is it repair, modernisation or both?
- Maintenance share estimated and documented
- Notice at least three months beforehand in text form
- Levy calculated at 8 per cent, funding deducted
- Cap of 3 or 2 euros per square metre in six years observed
Landlords and property managers equipping several flats receive, on request through the contact page, a quote with separate items. You can cost individual windows in the configurator.
Frequently asked questions
Must the landlord replace broken windows?
Yes. Under § 535 (1) sentence 2 BGB the landlord must keep the flat in a condition suitable for contractual use during the tenancy. That includes working, tight windows. They may not pass the cost of repair on to the rent as modernisation.
May the landlord raise the rent after replacing windows?
Only insofar as it is a modernisation, such as windows with better energy performance. They can then pass on 8 per cent of the modernisation costs a year, less the costs that a mere repair would have incurred. The increase is capped (as at September 2026).
How high may the rent increase after modernisation be at most?
Within six years the monthly rent may rise because of modernisation by no more than 3 euros per square metre, or by no more than 2 euros where the starting rent is below 7 euros per square metre (§ 559 (3a) BGB).
May I fit new windows myself as a tenant?
Not without the landlord's consent. The windows belong to the rented property and so to the landlord or, in an owners' association, to the community. Report defects to the landlord, who is responsible for putting them right.
Sources
- § 535 BGB – Inhalt und Hauptpflichten des Mietvertrags(opens in a new tab)
- § 555b BGB – Modernisierungsmaßnahmen(opens in a new tab)
- § 555c BGB – Ankündigung von Modernisierungsmaßnahmen(opens in a new tab)
- § 559 BGB – Mieterhöhung nach Modernisierungsmaßnahmen(opens in a new tab)
- § 559a BGB – Anrechnung von Drittmitteln(opens in a new tab)
- § 536 BGB – Mietminderung bei Sach- und Rechtsmängeln(opens in a new tab)
- Finanztip: Modernisierungsumlage – Mieterhöhung nach Modernisierung(opens in a new tab)
- vhw: Mietrechtsreform 2026 – Kabinettsentwurf (29.04.2026)(opens in a new tab)
- Miet-Check: Mietrechtsreform 2026 für Vermieter (29.07.2026)(opens in a new tab)
Ready for your project?
Configure your products to measure and see the price straight away – or send us your questions.