Replacing Windows in an Owners' Association: Resolution, Costs and Procedure under the WEG
8 minutes read
When windows are replaced in an owners' association, it is not the individual flat owner who decides but the community: under § 5 (2) of the German Condominium Act (WEG), external windows are compulsorily common property. Replacement therefore needs a resolution of the owners' meeting. In principle all owners bear the costs according to their shares, but the community can resolve a different allocation, for example by windows per flat. This article describes German law; if you live in a block of flats elsewhere, check your lease, management arrangements and local rules.
This article explains the legal position under the Condominium Act (WEG), typical resolution variants and how owners and managing agents organise the window replacement in practice. It does not replace legal advice; the declaration of division and earlier resolutions of your community may contain particularities.
Why Windows Are Common Property
§ 5 (2) WEG provides that parts of the building that are required for its existence or safety cannot be the subject of individually owned property. External windows protect the building from the weather and shape the façade, so they belong to the common property. According to "Wohnen im Eigentum", this applies even if the declaration of division assigns the windows to individually owned property; such a provision is ineffective to that extent. As a rule only the inside window board counts as individually owned property; frames, glass, hardware and roller shutters belong to the community.
This has consequences: no owner may replace windows on their own initiative, not even at their own cost. Conversely, any owner can require the community to deal with defective windows, for example by asking the managing agent to put the replacement on the agenda of the next meeting.
The Federal Court of Justice Ruling on Going It Alone
A judgment of the Federal Court of Justice (BGH) of 14 June 2019 (V ZR 254/17) shows how costly going it alone can be. An owner, wrongly assuming that the windows belonged to his individually owned property, had replaced his windows at his own cost and later demanded reimbursement from the community. The BGH refused: maintenance of the common property is a matter for the community, which decides on it. Anyone who acts without a resolution can in principle claim no reimbursement, even if all concerned laboured under the same mistake.
Maintenance or Structural Alteration?
The WEG distinguishes two categories, which have different consequences for costs:
| Category | Legal basis | Example | Resolution |
|---|---|---|---|
| Proper maintenance | § 19 (2) no. 2 WEG | Replacing defective windows with an equivalent specification | simple majority |
| Structural alteration | § 20 (1) WEG | Markedly different windows, e.g. changed division, different colour | simple majority |
Whether replacement with more energy-efficient windows is still maintenance or already a structural alteration depends on the individual case and is not assessed uniformly. A like-for-like replacement without material change counts as maintenance; some guides treat fitting markedly more energy-efficient or visually different windows as a structural alteration already. Since both can be decided by simple majority since the WEG reform, the practical difference lies mainly in the allocation of costs. If in doubt, have the classification checked before the meeting.
Who Bears the Costs?
Basic Rule
Under § 16 (2) sentence 1 WEG, each owner bears the costs of the community in proportion to their share. Funding often comes from the maintenance reserve, the building up of which belongs to proper management under § 19 (2) no. 4 WEG.
Different Cost Key
Under § 16 (2) sentence 2 WEG, the owners can resolve a different allocation for individual costs or particular kinds of cost. Common in practice: each owner bears the costs of the windows of their own flat. The declaration of division can also contain such a cost rule.
Structural Alterations
For structural alterations, § 21 WEG governs the costs. If an individual owner is permitted an alteration, they bear the costs themselves. All owners bear the costs according to shares if the measure was decided by more than two thirds of the votes cast and half of all co-ownership shares, unless it involves disproportionate costs, or if the costs pay back within a reasonable period.
Privileged Measures
§ 20 (2) WEG gives every owner a claim to reasonable structural alterations for certain purposes, among them protection against burglary. Anyone who wants burglar-resistant windows for their ground-floor flat, for example, can demand a corresponding resolution but then in principle bears the costs themselves under § 21 (1) WEG.
Uniform Appearance
The community determines the material, colour, division and look of the windows. According to "Wohnen im Eigentum", individual owners cannot simply choose cheap uPVC windows if the other windows are timber or aluminium. A resolution should therefore contain a specification that applies to all flats, including for later individual replacements.
How a Window Replacement in the WEG Proceeds
- Survey of condition: state of the windows, age, damage, energy condition.
- Advice: energy consultant or specialist firm, possibly with a view to funding.
- Obtain quotes: at least three comparable quotes with an identical description of work.
- Draft resolution: measure, specification, cost allocation, financing, award.
- Owners' meeting: resolution with the required majority.
- Award and execution by the managing agent, coordination with residents and tenants.
- Acceptance and documentation.
How to compare quotes objectively is shown in the article Comparing window quotes. For rented flats, tenancy-law rules also apply; more on this in the article Rented flat: who pays for new windows?.
Typical Points of Dispute and How to Avoid Them
- Different condition: some flats already have new windows, others still have old ones. A resolution should state whether windows replaced earlier at the owner's own cost are credited or have to be replaced.
- Cost key: anyone with many or large windows pays more with an allocation by windows than by co-ownership shares. Fix the key before the quotation phase.
- Schedule: replacement in all flats at the same time is cheaper but needs access to every flat. Clarify dates early.
- Execution: differing wishes on colour or glazing bars endanger the uniform look. The specification belongs in the resolution.
Funding in the WEG
Owners' associations can also apply for BEG funding for windows. The eligible costs are tiered: 30,000 euros for the first residential unit, 15,000 euros each for the second to sixth and 8,000 euros each from the seventh residential unit, with higher limits where an iSFP exists (as at September 2026). The application must be made before the contract is signed. Details in the article BAFA funding for windows.
Checklist for Owners and Managing Agents
- Check the declaration of division and earlier resolutions on cost allocation
- Classify the measure as maintenance or structural alteration
- Fix a uniform specification
- Expressly resolve the cost allocation
- Clarify financing from the reserve or a special levy
- Funding application before the contract is awarded
- Inform tenants and residents in good time
- Include a rule for windows already replaced in the resolution
For larger properties we put together quotes with uniform specification for all flats; talk to us via the contact page. You can cost individual window types beforehand in the configurator.
Frequently asked questions
Do windows in an owner-occupied flat belong to the individually owned part?
No. Under § 5 (2) WEG, external windows are compulsorily common property, because they are required for the existence and safety of the building. The prevailing view is that this applies even if the declaration of division states otherwise.
May I replace my windows in my own flat myself?
Not without a resolution of the owners' meeting. In 2019 the Federal Court of Justice decided that an owner who replaces windows on their own initiative at their own cost has in principle no claim to reimbursement against the community (V ZR 254/17).
Who pays for the window replacement in the WEG?
In principle all owners, according to their co-ownership shares (§ 16 (2) sentence 1 WEG). The owners can, however, resolve a different allocation for individual costs, for example that each pays for the windows of their own flat.
What majority is needed for the window replacement?
Since the WEG reform, maintenance measures and structural alterations can be decided by simple majority. Special conditions apply under § 21 (2) WEG to the question of whether all owners bear the costs of a structural alteration.
Sources
- § 5 WEG – Gegenstand und Inhalt des Sondereigentums(opens in a new tab)
- § 16 WEG – Nutzungen und Kosten(opens in a new tab)
- § 19 WEG – Regelung der Verwaltung und Benutzung durch Beschluss(opens in a new tab)
- § 20 WEG – Bauliche Veränderungen(opens in a new tab)
- § 21 WEG – Nutzungen und Kosten bei baulichen Veränderungen(opens in a new tab)
- LTO: BGH V ZR 254/17 zu Fenstern als Gemeinschaftseigentum(opens in a new tab)
- Wohnen im Eigentum: Kein Alleingang – Fenster gehören der WEG(opens in a new tab)
- WEG-Wissen: Fenstertausch in der WEG 2026 (31.08.2026)(opens in a new tab)
Ready for your project?
Configure your products to measure and see the price straight away – or send us your questions.