Right of Withdrawal for Made-to-Measure Goods: What Applies When Buying Windows and Doors to Size
7 minutes read
On the right of withdrawal for made-to-measure goods, a clear basic rule applies to windows and doors: a consumer who buys windows online or by telephone that are made to his or her individual measurements and wishes can generally not withdraw from the contract within 14 days. The basis is § 312g (2) no. 1 of the German Civil Code (BGB). There are exceptions mainly where the focus is not on a sale but on a contract for work and services including fitting. This article describes German law; if you are buying elsewhere in the EU or in the UK, check the consumer rules that apply in your country, as they may differ in detail.
Here you can find out what the legislator and the courts say, which categories of case exist and how to protect yourself against expensive wrong orders.
The Right of Withdrawal in Distance Selling: The Basic Rule
When consumers conclude a contract at a distance (online, by email, telephone) or away from business premises (for example at a home visit), § 312g (1) BGB gives them a right of withdrawal. Under § 355 BGB the period is 14 days, and no reason has to be given. For deliveries of goods, the period in principle begins only when you have received the goods, and not before the trader has properly informed you about the right of withdrawal.
Since 2026, § 356a BGB also obliges online traders to provide an electronic withdrawal function labelled "withdraw from contract" or something equivalent. This obligation concerns contracts for which there is a right of withdrawal at all.
The Exception for Made-to-Measure Goods Under § 312g (2) No. 1 BGB
The law excludes the right of withdrawal for "contracts for the supply of goods that are not prefabricated and for whose manufacture an individual selection or determination by the consumer is decisive or that are clearly tailored to the consumer's personal needs".
Windows made to measure typically meet these conditions several times over:
- Individual dimensions: width and height are matched to your wall opening to the millimetre.
- Individual specification: profile, glass, colour inside and outside, opening type, hand, glazing bars, hardware.
- No resale value: a window of 1,135 × 1,385 mm with anthracite outside and a DIN right hand fits practically no other house.
The underlying idea: the dealer should not be left sitting on goods that he could make only for you and can hardly use elsewhere.
What the ECJ Clarified in 2020
For a long time it was disputed whether the exclusion applies only once the manufacturer has begun production. On 21 October 2020 (case C-529/19, Möbel Kraft), the European Court of Justice decided: the exception applies regardless of whether production has already begun. The consumer cannot know the state of manufacture anyway, and the right of withdrawal must not depend on the progress of performance of the contract.
For you this means: even if you notice an hour after ordering that a dimension is wrong, there is no statutory entitlement to withdraw. Whether the supplier still allows a change is his voluntary decision.
The case itself is instructive for window buyers: a customer had ordered a fitted kitchen with individually chosen elements at a trade fair and withdrew shortly afterwards. The manufacturer had not yet started production. The ECJ did not accept this. It also pointed out that a trade fair stand may under certain circumstances count as business premises, in which case there is no right of withdrawal on the ground of a contract concluded away from business premises in the first place.
Typical Misconceptions When Buying Windows
- "I have 14 days anyway." Only for standard goods or where a contract for work and services exists that was concluded away from business premises or at a distance.
- "As long as nothing has been produced, I can cancel." Not after the ECJ ruling; only voluntarily or where the contract provides for it.
- "A deposit secures me a right to withdraw." A deposit changes nothing in the legal position.
- "As a tradesperson I can withdraw for my customer." Traders have no consumer right of withdrawal, even if the end customer is a private household.
When a Right of Withdrawal May Still Exist
The exception is not a blank cheque. There are situations in which consumers can withdraw despite individual manufacture:
| Situation | Classification |
|---|---|
| Windows in standard sizes from stock | Prefabricated goods: right of withdrawal exists in principle |
| Plain purchase made to measure in an online shop | Exception under § 312g (2) no. 1 generally applies |
| Supply and fitting as a single work, concluded away from business premises | May be a contract for work and services: right of withdrawal possible |
| Contract concluded in a shop or showroom | Not distance selling: no statutory right of withdrawal from the outset |
| Buyer acts as a trader | No consumer right of withdrawal |
Contract for Work and Services Instead of a Sale
In the case of a made-to-measure curved stairlift (judgment of 20 October 2021, I ZR 96/20), the Federal Court of Justice decided that the exception for made-to-measure goods is tailored to sales contracts and contracts for the supply of goods to be manufactured, but not in principle to contracts for work and services. What is decisive is which performance is the main one on an overall view. There the emphasis was on producing a functioning work: fitting a rail into the stairwell.
For windows this means: if you commission a firm to survey, remove the old windows, supply and fit properly, and this contract is concluded, for example, at a home visit, a right of withdrawal may exist. How a specific contract is to be classified depends on the individual case.
Cancellation and Changes: What Is Possible by Contract
Even without a statutory right of withdrawal, you can talk to the supplier. In practice the following often applies:
- Before production starts, corrections to dimensions or colours are sometimes still possible, possibly against processing costs.
- After production starts, material and production costs are incurred, which the supplier may require you to reimburse if he agrees to cancel.
- Contractual rights of withdrawal apply only if expressly agreed; read the terms and conditions on this.
Important: the supplier must inform you before the contract is concluded that there is no right of withdrawal. The ECJ emphasised this duty to inform in its ruling.
Rights in Respect of Defects Remain Unaffected
The exclusion of the right of withdrawal concerns only the possibility of ending the contract without reason. If a window is defective (wrong dimensions due to a manufacturing fault, damaged glass, faulty hardware), you are entitled to the statutory warranty rights. How these work is explained in the article on warranty and guarantee for windows and doors, and the practical procedure in the article on complaints about windows.
Note the difference, though: if the manufacturer made exactly to your wrong specifications, there is no defect. The risk of a measuring error is yours.
How to Protect Yourself Against Wrong Orders
- Have the survey done or checked by an experienced fitter; our article on measuring windows correctly helps with this.
- Check the hand and opening type for each window individually.
- Check the order confirmation immediately on receipt and report deviations without delay.
- Clarify before ordering whether and until when changes are possible.
- Keep the configuration, order confirmation and correspondence.
This article gives a general overview and does not replace legal advice in an individual case. For specific disputes, a consumer advice centre or a lawyer can help.
In the window configurator you see a complete overview of every item before you send. If you are unsure whether your dimensions and specification are right, use the contact with our team beforehand.
Frequently asked questions
Can I withdraw from windows made to measure within 14 days?
For the plain purchase of windows made to your individual measurements and wishes, the statutory right of withdrawal under § 312g (2) no. 1 of the German Civil Code (BGB) is generally excluded. According to the ECJ this applies even if production has not yet started.
Does the exclusion also apply if a tradesperson supplies and fits the windows?
Not automatically. If the production of a functioning work is the main point, there may be a contract for work and services, to which, under Federal Court of Justice case law, the exception does not in principle apply. Whether a right of withdrawal exists then also depends on how the contract was concluded.
Can the dealer still accept a cancellation?
Yes, voluntarily. Many suppliers allow changes or cancellations as long as manufacture has not been started, possibly against reimbursement of costs. Without a contractual arrangement, though, you have no entitlement to this.
Do I still have rights if there are defects?
Yes. The exclusion concerns only withdrawal without reason. Your statutory rights in respect of defects under §§ 434 ff. BGB remain fully in place.
Sources
- § 312g BGB – Widerrufsrecht (Gesetzestext)(opens in a new tab)
- § 355 BGB – Widerrufsrecht bei Verbraucherverträgen(opens in a new tab)
- § 356a BGB – Widerrufsfunktion(opens in a new tab)
- LTO: EuGH C-529/19 – Kein Widerruf bei Maßküche (21.10.2020)(opens in a new tab)
- IHK Hannover: BGH – Widerrufsrecht greift bei Werkverträgen (I ZR 96/20)(opens in a new tab)
- e-recht24: Widerrufsrecht bei Maßanfertigung (Januar 2026)(opens in a new tab)
Ready for your project?
Configure your products to measure and see the price straight away – or send us your questions.