External venetian blinds or roller shutters: the comparison on light, heat, security and appearance
7 minutes read
External venetian blinds or roller shutters: the decision depends on what matters more to you. An external venetian blind (known in German as a "Raffstore") steers light with tiltable aluminium slats and keeps the sun out without darkening the room. A roller shutter blacks out completely, adds insulation in winter and protects the window mechanically. Many builders therefore combine them: external venetian blinds for living and working rooms, roller shutters for bedrooms.
Both are external sun protection and therefore far more effective than internal blinds.
Construction: slats against curtain
External venetian blind (raffstore): the slats are usually made of roll-formed, anodised or powder-coated aluminium. They hang on lifting tapes and are guided at the sides in rails or on cables. When raised they are "gathered" in the box or under a cover, hence the German name. The tilt of the slats can be adjusted continuously.
Roller shutter: the curtain of plastic, aluminium or timber profiles is wound onto a shaft. It only has the positions open, closed and in between; light slots between the profiles let some light through as it is lowered, until the curtain is fully closed.
External venetian blinds or roller shutters: the comparison at a glance
| Criterion | External venetian blind | Roller shutter |
|---|---|---|
| Light control | continuous via slat angle | hardly, only via height and light slots |
| Sun protection with daylight | very good | limited |
| Blackout | not complete | very good |
| Thermal protection in winter | low | noticeable through air cushion and curtain |
| Wind stability | limited, wind sensor sensible | higher |
| Mechanical protection | low | made harder with anti-lift device |
| Noise in rain and wind | slats can rattle | closed curtain quieter |
| Appearance | filigree, architectural | closed, classic |
| Care | clean slats individually | wash down the curtain |
Light and glare protection: the strength of the external venetian blind
The biggest advantage of the external venetian blind is light control. With the slats at an angle, they keep out direct sun and steer diffuse light into the room. At a computer workstation this prevents glare without you having to switch the lights on.
Modern systems go further. According to the specialist literature, there are daylight versions in which the upper slats are set differently or perforated: light comes in at the top, while glare protection is kept at the bottom. For offices, home offices and large glazed areas this is a real gain in comfort.
The roller shutter cannot do this in the same way. Lowered halfway, it darkens the upper part of the window, exactly where most daylight comes in. If you want to keep heat out during the day, you quickly end up sitting in artificial light with the roller shutter closed. Conversely, this very property is an advantage in the bedroom: mornings stay dark, and street lights do not disturb at night.
Heat: summer and winter
Summer heat protection
Both systems act outside, before the solar radiation hits the pane. That is decisive: internal sun protection stops the heat in the room only after it has already passed through the glass. An external venetian blind reduces the heat load and lets light in at the same time. A closed roller shutter keeps out even more heat, but darkens the room. How solar control glass and external protection work together is covered in the article on summer heat protection for windows.
Thermal protection in winter
Here the roller shutter has the edge. The closed curtain creates an air cushion in front of the window and reduces heat loss at night. Foam-filled aluminium profiles strengthen the effect. An external venetian blind, with its thin slats, has hardly any insulating effect.
In winter during the day you want to let the sun in with both systems: solar gains through the window reduce heating demand.
Wind, weather and noise
External venetian blinds are more sensitive to wind. According to the specialist literature, standard systems can be used up to about 17.4 m/s (Beaufort 7), newer developments up to about 25 m/s. Wind stability depends on the width and the type of guidance; rail guidance is more stable than cable guidance. A wind sensor that automatically raises the system in stronger wind is practically part of the basic equipment, especially in exposed locations and on upper floors.
Roller shutters are sturdier. The curtain runs in guide rails and withstands stronger wind too. In rain and wind they are generally quieter than slats.
Security
A closed roller shutter with an anti-lift device makes it harder to push it up from outside and protects the window from quick attacks. An external venetian blind offers hardly any such protection. For both, however: during the day and when you are away they are often open, and then the window fitting decides. The German police therefore recommend burglar-resistant windows from RC 2 (EN 1627); readers in the UK can look for PAS 24 certification. More in the article Burglar protection for windows: RC1 to RC3.
Appearance and architecture
External venetian blinds look filigree and suit modern architecture with large glazed areas. In various slat widths and colours they can be matched to the facade. Roller shutters look more closed. With a concealed box, for example as a frame-mounted roller shutter, they are nearly invisible when open.
Both systems need a box or a cover. Depending on the slat pack, external venetian blinds need some space above the window, which must be allowed for in planning.
Decision guide
The following recommendations are rules of thumb. In an individual case, location, architecture and personal preference decide, and not infrequently the budget too, because external venetian blinds are generally more complex in their technology.
- Living room, study, kitchen: external venetian blind for light and glare protection
- Bedroom, children's room: roller shutter for blackout and quiet
- Large glazed areas facing south and west: external venetian blind with sun automation and wind sensor
- Exposed, windy location: roller shutter or external venetian blind with rail guidance
- Ground floor with security requirements: roller shutter with anti-lift device plus RC 2 window
- Older building, retrofit: roller shutter as a surface-mounted system or external venetian blind with a surface-mounted box
Combinations and special solutions
In practice it does not have to be either-or. Many houses use a combination:
- By compass direction: external venetian blinds on the south and west sides, where sun and glare are the issue, roller shutters on the north and street side.
- By room: external venetian blinds in the living area, roller shutters in bedrooms and children's rooms.
- With the same look: both systems can be ordered in the same colour; with concealed or frame-mounted boxes the facade stays calm.
A further alternative for large glazed areas and terraces is fabric vertical awnings with side zip guidance. They combine good sun protection with a view through, but offer neither blackout nor burglar protection.
Automation pays off particularly with external venetian blinds
Because external venetian blinds are sensitive to wind and the slat angle needs adjusting through the day, automation shows its strengths here. Sun and wind sensors run the system by themselves, even when nobody is at home. More in the article on Somfy io-homecontrol.
Checklist before ordering
- Decide the use of each room: light, darkness or both?
- Check compass direction and exposure to wind
- Clarify space for the box or cover above the window
- Plan drive and automation: motor, sun and wind sensor
- Match colour and appearance to window and facade
- In multi-family houses and owners' associations, obtain consent for the facade change
Made-to-measure roller shutters and external venetian blinds are in the roller shutters section. For joint planning with new windows, use the configurator.
Frequently asked questions
What is the main difference between an external venetian blind and a roller shutter?
An external venetian blind (raffstore) consists of individually tiltable aluminium slats with which light and sun can be steered continuously. A roller shutter is a closed curtain that mainly blacks out, insulates and protects the window mechanically.
Does an external venetian blind withstand wind?
Only to a limited extent. For standard external venetian blinds, use up to about 17.4 m/s wind speed (force 7) is quoted, newer systems up to around 25 m/s. A wind sensor raises them automatically in stronger wind.
Can an external venetian blind black out completely?
Not completely. Even closed slats let some light through at the edges and slat joints. If you want real darkness in the bedroom, a roller shutter is the better choice.
What protects better against summer heat?
Both are far more effective as external sun protection than internal blinds. The external venetian blind has the advantage that it keeps the sun out and still lets daylight into the room; the roller shutter darkens the room more.
Sources
- Wikipedia – Raffstore (Aufbau, Führung, Windstabilität, Lichtlenkung)(opens in a new tab)
- Wikipedia – Rollladen (Bauarten, Materialien, Hochschiebesicherung)(opens in a new tab)
- Passipedia – Anforderungen an Fenster (solare Gewinne, g-Wert)(opens in a new tab)
- Polizeiliche Kriminalprävention – Einbruchschutz am Fenster(opens in a new tab)
Ready for your project?
Configure your products to measure and see the price straight away – or send us your questions.