Roller shutter types compared: surface-mounted, frame-mounted and lintel-box roller shutters
7 minutes read
There are three basic types of roller shutter: the integral or lintel roller shutter, whose box sits in the masonry above the window; the frame-mounted (top-mounted) roller shutter, whose box is fitted directly on the window frame and supplied with the window; and the surface-mounted roller shutter, a self-contained system fitted outside on the facade or in the reveal. Which type suits depends mainly on whether you are building new, replacing windows or simply retrofitting.
This overview shows the differences and helps with the first decision. The details of the individual types are in separate articles.
The three roller shutter types at a glance
| Feature | Integral/lintel roller shutter | Frame-mounted roller shutter | Surface-mounted roller shutter |
|---|---|---|---|
| Position of the box | in the masonry above the window | on the window frame, within the wall | outside in front of the facade or in the reveal |
| Visibility outside | invisible | invisible, can be rendered over | box visible |
| Typical use | new build, existing building with an existing box | window replacement, new build | retrofitting, older building without a box |
| Intervention in the wall | lintel must be prepared | window opening planned together | hardly any, fitted onto the wall |
| Thermal insulation | old boxes often critical | insulated boxes, part of the window | box outside the insulated envelope |
| Inspection access | usually from inside | inside or outside, depending on system | from outside |
Integral or lintel roller shutters
With the classic integral roller shutter, the box sits in the lintel above the window and cannot be seen from outside. In many houses from the second half of the 20th century, this box was built on site from timber or lightweight boards and fitted with an inspection cover facing the room.
Advantages:
- Invisible outside, so the facade stays calm
- In a new build, the box can be planned in as an insulated lintel element
Disadvantages:
- Old boxes are often uninsulated and leaky and therefore a thermal bridge
- The inspection cover inside is often a weak point for airtightness and sound insulation
When replacing windows, the existing box is often kept. You should then have it insulated and sealed, otherwise the coldest spot in the wall sits directly above the new, airtight window. Condensation and mould then appear preferably on the underside of the box and at the adjoining reveals.
Frame-mounted roller shutters
The frame-mounted roller shutter is the solution for window replacement and new builds. The box is fitted on the window frame at the factory and supplied with the window as one unit. It sits within the wall opening, can be rendered over on the outside and is therefore barely recognisable from outside.
Advantages:
- Window and roller shutter come from one source and are matched to each other
- Insulated boxes with defined connections for insulation and render
- Usually no visible inspection hatch in the room inside, depending on the system
Disadvantages:
- The glazed area becomes smaller by the height of the box if the structural opening stays the same
- Must be specified at the window planning stage; later retrofitting is laborious
More in the article on frame-mounted roller shutters when replacing windows.
Surface-mounted roller shutters
With the surface-mounted roller shutter, box, guide rails and curtain form a self-contained, closed system. It is fitted outside on the facade or in the window reveal. The wall construction and the window stay untouched.
Advantages:
- Ideal for retrofitting, including on existing windows
- No new thermal bridge in the wall, because the box sits outside the insulated envelope
- Maintenance from outside, no inspection cover in the room
Disadvantages:
- The box is visible from outside; square, round or bevelled shapes and colour matching soften this
- Fitted in the reveal, it reduces the clear window height slightly
In detail in the article Surface-mounted roller shutters: ideal for retrofitting.
Materials for the roller shutter curtain
Regardless of the installation type, you choose the material of the slats:
- Plastic (PVC): light, inexpensive, easy to care for. According to the specialist literature, the width without reinforcement is limited to about 2 m.
- Aluminium, roll-formed and foam-filled: thin-walled, with foam filling for insulation and noise damping; suitable for larger widths.
- Aluminium, extruded: thick-walled and particularly sturdy, often for security requirements.
- Timber: good summer heat protection and natural appearance, but needs more care and is more expensive.
For large balcony doors and lift-and-slide doors, aluminium is almost always the choice because of the width.
Drives: strap, crank or motor
- Strap winder: the simplest solution. According to the specialist literature, the pulling force on the strap should not exceed 90 N, so a strap is unsuitable for large and heavy curtains.
- Crank: for heavier roller shutters, without a mains connection.
- Tubular motor: sits in the shaft and is operated by switch, radio remote or app. Modern radio motors offer obstacle detection and electronic end positions.
How to convert existing roller shutters to a motor is explained in the article on retrofitting a roller shutter motor.
Security: anti-lift device
A lowered roller shutter can be pushed up from outside if it is not secured. An anti-lift device, usually a locking spring on the shaft or a bolt in the bottom rail, prevents this. It does not replace burglar-resistant windows, though: during the day the roller shutter is open, and then the window fitting decides. The German police therefore recommend windows from resistance class RC 2 (EN 1627). In the UK, the comparable benchmark is PAS 24 certification; ask your supplier which applies.
Common mistakes when choosing
- Overlooking the old box: if you replace only the windows and leave the uninsulated lintel box, you move the condensation from the glass to the box.
- Forgetting the box height: with a frame-mounted roller shutter, the glazed area shrinks if the opening is not adapted.
- Curtain too heavy for the strap: large aluminium curtains can hardly be operated with a strap, so choose a crank or motor from the start.
- No power supply planned: if you want to motorise later, at least lay a conduit or cable route to the box when replacing windows or building new.
- Confusing sun protection and blackout: if mainly glare protection in daylight is wanted, an external venetian blind is often better advice. You will find the comparison in the article on external venetian blinds or roller shutters.
Roller shutters and energy
A closed roller shutter acts in winter like an additional air cushion in front of the window and reduces heat loss at night. In summer it is far more effective as external sun protection than curtains or internal blinds, because it intercepts the radiation before it passes through the glass into the room. The precondition for the positive effect, however, is an insulated and airtight box; a draughty old box can cancel the saving again. If you are planning new windows anyway, you should therefore not treat the box as a side issue but choose it with the same care as profile and glazing.
Checklist: which roller shutter type suits?
- New build: frame-mounted roller shutter or insulated lintel element, agreed early with the window plan
- Window replacement with a new box: frame-mounted roller shutter
- Window replacement with an old box: insulate and seal the box, or replace it
- Retrofitting without window replacement: surface-mounted roller shutter
- Large widths: aluminium curtain, motor drive
- Security: anti-lift device and burglar-resistant window fitting
- Comfort: radio motor with feedback if schedules or smart home are wanted
Made-to-measure roller shutters and external venetian blinds are in the roller shutters section. If you are planning windows and a frame-mounted roller shutter together, put both together directly in the configurator.
Frequently asked questions
What types of roller shutter are there?
There are mainly three installation types: the integral or lintel roller shutter with the box in the masonry, the frame-mounted (top-mounted) roller shutter whose box sits on the window frame, and the surface-mounted roller shutter, a self-contained system fitted outside on the facade or in the reveal.
Which roller shutter is best when replacing windows?
When replacing windows, the frame-mounted roller shutter is often the obvious choice, because it is supplied and installed together with the window. If a shutter is to be added to a new window without touching the lintel, a surface-mounted roller shutter is the simpler solution.
Which material is best for roller shutter slats?
Plastic is light and inexpensive but limited in width. Aluminium, usually foam-filled, is sturdier and suitable for larger widths. Timber has become rare and needs more care. The choice depends on width, appearance, budget and security requirements.
Can a roller shutter prevent a break-in?
A roller shutter with an anti-lift device makes it harder to push it up from outside. It does not replace a burglar-resistant window fitting, because during the day and when you are away with the shutter open, the window itself is the barrier.
Sources
Ready for your project?
Configure your products to measure and see the price straight away – or send us your questions.