Safety glass in windows: toughened (ESG), laminated (VSG) and when it is required
7 minutes read
ESG and VSG (toughened and laminated safety glass) are the two main types of safety glass in windows. ESG is thermally toughened, particularly break-resistant and, if it fails, breaks into small, blunt crumbs. VSG consists of at least two panes with a tear-resistant interlayer; when it breaks, the splinters stay stuck to the interlayer and the pane stays closed. Under DIN 18008 in Germany, safety glass is required above all for overhead glazing and fall-protection glazing. In the UK, the equivalent rules are in BS 6206 and Approved Document K, so check your local requirements.
ESG: toughened safety glass
Manufacture
ESG is made from ordinary float glass that is heated to over 600 °C and then cooled abruptly with air nozzles from both sides. The surface therefore solidifies faster than the core, creating a compressive stress in the surface. The result: a crack finds it hard to form. Whereas ordinary float glass has a bending strength of around 40 MPa, toughened glass reaches values between 120 and 200 MPa.
Breakage behaviour
If ESG does break, the whole pane disintegrates into many small, mostly blunt-edged crumbs. The risk of injury is therefore low. However, the opening is then free: after breakage, ESG offers no protection against falling through or entry.
Limitations
- No later processing: cutting, drilling and edge work must be done before toughening.
- Spontaneous breakage: tiny nickel sulphide inclusions can expand in sunshine or with temperature changes and make ESG shatter without external cause. The heat-soak test counters this: the glass is held for several hours at 280 to 300 °C so that vulnerable panes break at the factory. Glass tested in this way is called ESG-H.
- Marking: under DIN EN 12150-1, ESG must be permanently marked with the manufacturer and standard designation, usually with a small stamp in the corner.
VSG: laminated safety glass
Construction
VSG consists of two or more panes of glass firmly bonded with a plastic interlayer, usually PVB in 0.38 mm layers. The panes can be ordinary float glass or heat-strengthened glass. According to DIN EN 14449, the interlayer should hold the glass pieces on breakage, limit the opening, ensure residual load-bearing capacity and reduce the risk of injury.
Breakage behaviour
When VSG breaks, a spider's web of cracks forms, but the pane stays in the frame and continues to close the opening. That is precisely why VSG is used when the opening must stay closed even after damage or when falling shards must be avoided.
Additional functions
- Sound insulation: VSG attenuates sound better than monolithic glass of the same thickness; special acoustic interlayers strengthen the effect.
- Burglar resistance: VSG classified to DIN EN 356 withstands attack. Classes P1A to P5A describe resistance to being thrown through (ball drop test), P6B to P8B resistance to breaking through (axe test).
- UV protection: the interlayer filters out a large part of UV radiation; the interlayer manufacturer gives exact figures.
ESG and VSG compared
| Property | ESG | VSG |
|---|---|---|
| Construction | one toughened pane | several panes with interlayer |
| Breaking strength | high (120–200 MPa) | depends on the individual panes |
| Break pattern | small crumbs, opening free | splinters stick to interlayer, pane stays in frame |
| Residual load-bearing capacity | none | present |
| Overhead / fall protection | not on its own | yes, after sizing |
| Burglar resistance | no | with a DIN EN 356 class |
| Processing after manufacture | practically impossible | limited (if made from float glass) |
When safety glass is required
The design and construction of glass in buildings in Germany is governed by the DIN 18008 series of standards. It consists of six parts, including Part 2 for linearly supported glazing (windows and doors) and Part 4 for fall-protection glazing. Whether a glazing falls under the requirements depends on its function and installation situation.
Overhead glazing
For glass roofs, canopies and sloping glazing, for instance in a conservatory, the German Federal Association of Flat Glass guide says that for single glazing or the lower pane of an insulating glass unit, only VSG made of float glass or heat-strengthened glass, or wired glass, may be used. ESG alone is not permitted underneath because falling crumbs could endanger people.
Fall-protection glazing
If there is a drop behind a floor-to-ceiling window or a glass balustrade, the glazing must be sized as fall protection unless there is a separate railing. In Germany, the state building codes require guarding where areas are regularly used and there is a height difference of more than 1 m. For categories A and B under DIN 18008-4, VSG with a 1.52 mm PVB interlayer is required (status: September 2026). The parapet heights themselves are set by the relevant state building code. More in the article on panoramic windows and fixed glazing.
Vertical glazing at great height
For monolithic ESG as single glazing, the guide gives a maximum installation height of 4 m. Above that, coarse-breaking types of glass or heat-soaked ESG-H are needed.
Circulation areas and workplaces
In areas where people can walk or fall into glass, for example with floor-to-ceiling glazing in corridors, at all-glass doors or in public buildings, glass with safe breakage behaviour is appropriate. Additional regulations apply to workplaces and public buildings. Which rules apply in an individual case is for planners and the building authority to clarify; this article does not replace legal advice.
Safety glass in patio and lift-and-slide doors
With large sliding doors, safety glass is not required in every case but is often sensible:
- ESG on the outside increases break resistance against impact, for example from balls or garden furniture.
- VSG on the inside protects against injury if someone walks into the pane and, with a P class, can improve burglar protection.
- Large formats often need thicker or toughened panes anyway to take wind and climatic loads.
If burglar protection matters to you, combine VSG with tested hardware; burglar-resistant glass alone is not enough because windows and doors are frequently levered open. Details are in the article sliding door security. You should allow for the extra weight of VSG when choosing the hardware; see Large glass areas: weight, structure and glass thickness.
TVG: the intermediate form
Besides ESG there is heat-strengthened glass (TVG). It is also heated but cooled more slowly. Its strength lies between float glass and ESG, and it breaks into larger pieces that hold together better in a laminate. TVG is therefore often used as an individual pane in VSG, for example for overhead or fall-protection glazing, where residual load-bearing capacity is required after breakage.
How to recognise safety glass
- ESG: a small stamp in one corner with the standard designation EN 12150.
- VSG: often marked as well; at the edge you can see several layers of glass with interlayer.
- In insulating glass: the details are on the spacer in the cavity or in the delivery documents.
Checklist
- Clarify the function of the glazing: overhead, fall protection, circulation area, burglar protection?
- Have the manufacturer size the glass build-up to DIN 18008
- For ESG at great height: ESG-H with heat-soak test
- For burglar protection: VSG with P class plus tested hardware
- Allow for the extra weight in hardware and installation
You choose the glazing for your windows and doors in the configurator. For special glazing such as fall-protection or burglar-resistant build-ups, we are happy to prepare a quotation via the contact form.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between ESG and VSG?
ESG (toughened safety glass) is thermally toughened and breaks into many small, blunt crumbs. VSG (laminated safety glass) consists of several panes with an interlayer; when it breaks, the splinters stick to the interlayer and the pane stays in the frame as a whole.
When is VSG required?
Under DIN 18008, among other cases for overhead glazing (the lower pane) and for fall-protection glazing. Walk-on and accessible glazing also have special requirements. The glass manufacturer sizes the specific build-up.
Can ESG be cut to size afterwards?
No, not in practice. Cutting, drilling and edge work must be done before toughening; afterwards, processing is possible only to a very limited extent.
Does VSG protect against burglary?
Only VSG with the appropriate classification to DIN EN 356 is burglar-resistant. Classes P1A to P5A stand for resistance to being thrown through, P6B to P8B for resistance to breaking through. For vulnerable windows the German police give laminated safety glass from P4A.
Sources
- BF-Merkblatt 019 – Leitfaden zur Glasbemessung nach DIN 18008(opens in a new tab)
- BF-Merkblatt 013 – VSG im Bauwesen(opens in a new tab)
- Einscheibensicherheitsglas – Wikipedia(opens in a new tab)
- Verbundsicherheitsglas – Wikipedia(opens in a new tab)
- K-EINBRUCH – Sicherheitstipps Fenster(opens in a new tab)
- Umwehrung – Wikipedia(opens in a new tab)
Ready for your project?
Configure your products to measure and see the price straight away – or send us your questions.